Appeals received for Stage Two

General information about the appeals process is available on the Environment Court website. An annotated version of the chapters and maps, showing provisions under appeal, is available here.

All correspondence relating to appeals on any stages of the Proposed District Plan must be directed to dpappeals@qldc.govt.nz. 

Council Memoranda and Court Directions

Appeals Table and Spreadsheet

Appeals received for Stage Two

 


Date Lodged


Environment Court #


Appellant


Section 274 Parties


Status

 3 April 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-016

- Chapter 24: Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Hanan E and M

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Appendix 5

- Appendix 6

- Hanan DM

- Banco Trustees Ltd & Others

- Boxer Hill Trust

- Monk R

Notice of Withdrawal

-Ken Swain, Jonathan Newson, Judith Hanan, David Hanan, Ann Barrowclough, Garrick and Jillian Tremain, Ian and Patricia Henderson, David and Elizabeth Palmer, and Leo and Rayna Toshach (Decision on Waivers)

 Appeal Lodged

Consent Order Issued

 

Erratum

Decision issued

 3 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-017

- Chapter 29: Transport

Willowridge Developments Ltd

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

 

- RCL Queenstown Pty Ltd, RCL Henley Downs Ltd, RCL Jacks Point Ltd

Appendix 1

-  Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Queenstown Country Club Ltd and Queenstown Commercial Ltd

Memorandum of QCC and Qtn Commercial Withdrawing Interest in Transport

 

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings

- Well Smart Investments Group

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Consent Order

Consent Order

Consent Order

3 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-018

- Chapter 24: Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Guthrie M

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3

 

 

Appeal Withdrawn- notice of withdrawal

Consent Order Issued

3 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-019

- Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Nelson L and J

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Moloney D

- Hill RW and DK 

- Robertson D

- Harwood S

- Hurle N

- Nancekivell M and P

- Rouse W

- Williamson S

 Appeal withdrawn

Notice of Withdrawal

3 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-020

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Van Asch H and A

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3

 

- AEM Property (2017) Ltd

 

- Lawrence S

Notice of Withdrawal

 

- Caran Family Trust

- Crown Investment Trust

- JLMD Family Trust

- Rob Ffiske Family Trust

 Appeal Lodged

Consent Order Issued

Notice of Withdrawal

3 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-021

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Feeley A, Borrie E and LP Trustees Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Hanan DM

- Hanan EA, JM, J and D

- Banco Trustees Ltd & Others

 Appeal Lodged

6 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-022

Chapter 29 - Transport

RCL Henley Downs Ltd and Others

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Queenstown Country Club Ltd and Queenstown Commercial Ltd

    Memorandum of QCC and Qtn Commercial Withdrawing Interest in Transport

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings

- Kawerau Jet

- Well Smart Investments Group

 Appeal Lodged

 

 

 

 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-023

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

 

McQuilkin T and A P McQuilkin Family Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3

Notice of Withdrawal

Amended Notice of Appeal 



Appeal Lodged- Part withdrawn as appeal relates to Topic 31 – Rezoning 

Consent Order issued

6 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-024

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

 

Donaldson R

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3

- X-Ray Trust 

- Millbrook Country Club Ltd

- Jan Andersson Family Trust

- Breen G and Nicholas F

- Donovan P and R

- Millbrook Owners-Members Committee

- Rutherford I and McPherson J

- Shepherd D and A

- Trustees of the HNT Trust

- Trustees of the Kezza Family Trust

- Trustees of the Thomas Lifestyle Trusts

- Williamson S

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

 

6 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-025

Visitor Accommodation Sub-Zones Overlay 

Matagouri Spirit Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

 

Appeal Resolved

Consent Order

6 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-026

Chapter 25 - Earthworks

Queenstown Trails Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

 

- Kāi Tahu

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings

- Wayfare Group Limited

 Appeal Lodged

 6 May 2019  

ENV-2019-CHC-027

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin

Chapter 30 – Energy and Utilities 

Transpower New Zealand Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Appendix 5

- Aurora Energy Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-028

Wakatipu Basin
Rezoning

Grant E and G

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2 

- Guillot C and Y and Cook Adam Trustees Ltd

 Appeal lodged

Consent Order-Topic 31

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-029

Wakatipu Basin

Rezoning

Site specific text provisions

Outstanding Natural Landscape Line

Urban Growth Boundary 

Queenstown Country Club Ltd and Queenstown Commercial Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

Amended Notice of Appeal

Memorandum of counsel re amended notice of appeal

 

- Bridesdale Farm Developments Ltd

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

 Appeal Lodged

Consent Order (ONL Part of  Appeal Resolved)

Consent Order Topic 31

7 May 2019

 ENV-2019-CHC-030

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones Rezoning (Bob’s Peak)

ZJV (NZ) Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

 

- Skyline Enterprises Ltd

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

 Appeal Lodged

7 May 2019

 ENV-2019-CHC-031

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Outstanding Natural Feature

MacDonald M and Anderson S

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

 

Appeal Withdrawn

Notice of Withdrawal

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-032

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development 

Broomfield D and Woodlot Properties Ltd

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2

- Caran Family Trust

- Crown Investment Trust

- Felzar Properties Ltd, Morven Ferry Ltd, Strain A, S and S, United Estates Ranch Ltd, Wakatipu Equities Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

Paul and Anna Horrell as trustees of the Peak View Trust

Appeal Resolved 

Consent Order (Wakatipu Basin Rezoning Part of Appeal Resolved)

Consent Order issued

Consent Order -Littles Road

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-033

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

 

Trustees of the Hamilton Hayden Family Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Edmonds T

- Kilkenny R

- Pollock B

- Trustees of the Home Farm Holdings Trust

- Trustees of the T&B Family Trust

- Wilkinson J and Thomssen T Notice of Withdrawal 

- Veint J and D

- Williamson S

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-034

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 43 - Millbrook

 

Trustees of the Spruce Grove Trust

- Appendix 1 

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Appendix 5

- Burridge P

- Holm M

- Mahan G and S

- Mehrtens R

- Ashall L

- Barkle A and S

- Barney B and K

- Bates T and Hoffmann G

- Bell P and T

- Hadlow A and K

- Hotel Villa Company No. 1

- Landels J

- McGrath T and J

- Millbrook Country Club Ltd

- Morris A and M

- Springford A and S

- Turner L

- Walrus Jack Trustee Ltd

Appeal Lodged

 

 Decision issued

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-035

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 43 - Millbrook 

Trustees of the Boundary Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

-  Barkle A and S

- Bates T and Hoffmann G

- Bell P and T

- Hadlow A and K

- Landels J

- Millbrook Country Club Ltd

- Springford A and S

- Turner L

- Walrus Jack Trustee Ltd

Appeal Lodged

 

Decision issued 

7 May 2019

 ENV-2019-CHC-036

Wakatipu Basin

Rezoning

Trustees of the Burgess Duke Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Greenslade M K

Notice of Withdrawal

 

Gibbston Microgreens and Maria Chocano Decision on Waiver

Appeal Lodged

Environment Court Decision 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-037

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Trojan Helmet Ltd

- Appendix 1 

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Appendix 5

- Hanan EA, JM, J and D 

- Banco Trustees Ltd & Others

- Hogans Gully Farming Ltd

- Blair J

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Otago Regional Council

- Remarkables Park Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order -Topic 31 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-038

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Boxer Hill Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Hadley R

- Otago Regional Council

- Andersson J

- Wilkinson J and Thomssen T

Notice of Withdrawal

 Appeal Lodged

Consent Order Issued

Environment Court Decision 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-039

Chapter 29 – Transport

Chapter 31 – Signs Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones

Rezoning (Shotover Delta)

Queenstown Airport Corporation

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- ZJV (NZ) Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- ZJV (NZ) Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-040

Wakatipu Basin

Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Cassidy Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

-Greenslade M K

Notice of Withdrawal

 Appeal Lodged

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-041

Wakatipu Basin
Rezoning

Outstanding Natural Landscape Line

SYZ Investments Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

Tussock Rise Limited

 Appeal Withdrawn 

Notice of Withdrawal

 

7 May 2019

 

ENV-2019-CHC-042

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Muspratt J C

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

 

Notice of withdrawal

Amended Notice of Appeal

 

 

Tussock Rise Limited

Appeal Lodged  Part withdrawn as appeal relates to Topic 31 – Rezoning

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-043

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones Rezoning (Bob’s Peak) 

Skyline Enterprises Ltd

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3 

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Commercial Parapenters

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- ZJV (NZ) Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

Tussock Rise Limited

Appeal Lodged 

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-044

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin

Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

 

Wills G and Burden T

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3 

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, Morven Ferry Ltd, Strain A, S and S, Crown Investment Trust, United Estates Ranch Ltd, Wakatipu Equities Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order (Wakatipu Basin Rezoning Part of Appeal Resolved)’

 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-045

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin

Banco Trustees, McCulloch Trustees 2004 and Others

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3

- Hanan EA, JM, J and D 

- Trustees of Boxer Hill Trust

-Ken Swain, Jonathan Newson, Judith Hanan, David Hanan, Ann Barrowclough, Garrick and Jillian Tremain, Ian and Patricia Henderson, David and Elizabeth Palmer, and Leo and Rayna Toshach (Decision on Waivers)

Tussock Rise Limited

Appeal Lodged

Consent Order Issued

 

Erratum 

Decision issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-046

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

 

Martin J

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3 

 

Appeal Withdrawn

Notice of Withdrawal 

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-047

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning 

Henry M P

- Appendix 1a 

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 1c

- Appendix 1d

- Appendix 1e

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3

- G W Stalker Family Trust

- Tylden M

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

Notice of Withdrawal

Environment Court Decision

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-048

Wakatipu Basin

Rezoning

 

Hardley T

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

Memorandum Withdrawing Part of Appeal

Amended Notice of Appeal

 

- AEM Property (2017) Ltd

 

- Lawrence S

Notice of Withdrawal

 

- Woodlot Properties Ltd

- Caran Family Trust

- Crown Investment Trust

- JLMD Family Trust

- Rob Fiske Family Trust

Appeal Lodged 

Part withdrawn as appeal relates to Topic 31 - rezoning

Notice of Withdrawal

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-049

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones

 

Glen Dene Ltd and Burdon S

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2a

- Appendix 2b

- Appendix 3

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- ZJV (NZ) Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-050

Wakatipu Basin Outstanding Natural Landscape Line

McLintock C M and New Zealand Trustee Services Ltd and Others

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

 

Appeal Withdrawn

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-051

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning 

X-Ray Trust Ltd and Avenue Trust

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2 

- Donaldson R

- Hadley J and R

- Andersson J

- McGuinness PA Ltd

Appeal withdrawn

Notice of Withdrawl

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-052

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin

Wakatipu Investments Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, Morven Ferry Ltd, Strain A, S and S, Crown Investment Trust, United Estates Ranch Ltd, Wakatipu Equities Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

- Brett Giddens Trust

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-053

Wakatipu Basin
Rezoning

Bamford J and R

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

 Appeal Lodged

Consent Order

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-054

Chapter 29 - Transport

 

Safari Group of Companies Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

 

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings

- Well Smart Investments Group

Appeal Withdrawn

 

Notice of Withdrawal

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-055

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Urban Growth Boundary

Outstanding Natural Landscape Line

Middleton Family Trust

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 1c

- Appendix 2

- Tucker Beach Residents Society Incorporated

- Muspratt J

Appeal Lodged

Environment Court Decision 

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-056

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Strain A, S and S

- Appendix 1a

- Appendix 1b

- Appendix 2 

 

Appeal Lodged

 

Environment Court Decision 

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-057

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 29 – Transport

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones

Queenstown Park Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Kāi Tahu

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Blackmans Creek No. 1 LP & Soho Ski Area, Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings, Treble Cone Investments Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal

 

Appeal Lodged 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-058

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 29 – Transport

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones

Rezoning (Shotover Delta and Queenstown Town Centre)

Remarkables Park Ltd

- Appendix 1

-Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Kāi Tahu

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- ZJV (NZ) Ltd

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Blackmans Creek No. 1 LP & Soho Ski Area, Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings, Treble Cone Investments Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal 

 

Appeal Lodged 

 

Consent Order-Transport 

Consent Order - Open Space

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-059

Wakatipu Basin

Ladies Mile (Building Restriction Area) 

Boyd D 

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Laurel Hills Limited

 Appeal Lodged

May 7 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-060

Chapter 24- Wakatipu Basin 

TJ Investments

Appendix 1

- Otago Regional Council

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, Morven Ferry Ltd, Strain A, S and S, Crown Investment Trust, United Estates Ranch Ltd, Wakatipu Equities Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

Appeal Lodged

Consent Order Issued

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-061

Chapter 29 – Transport
Visitor Accommodation

Airbnb Australia Pty Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

Appendix 6

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Majordomo Ltd

- Touch of Spice Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Glencoe Station Ltd, Glendhu Bay Trustees Ltd, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings, Mt Christina Ltd, Crown Investment Trust

 Appeal Lodged

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-062

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 29 – Transport

Visitor Accommodation

Well Smart Investments Group 

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- RCL Queenstown Pty Ltd, RCL Henley Downs Ltd, RCL Jacks Point Ltd

Appendix 1

- Transpower New Zealand

    Memorandum by Transpower withdrawing part of interest

- Kāi Tahu

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Queenstown Country Club Ltd and Queenstown Commercial Ltd  
  Memorandum of QCC and Qtn Commercial Withdrawing Interest in Transport

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Blackmans Creek No. 1 LP & Soho Ski Area, Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings, Treble Cone Investments Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order- Chapter 25- Earthworks

 

Consent Order (Topic 28)

 

Withdrawal - Visitor Accommodation

 

 

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-063

 

Chapter 29 – Transport

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin
(Informal Airports)

B Giddens Trust

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings

- Well Smart Investments Group

Notice of Withdrawal (Appeal Withdrawn)

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-064

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin

(Informal Airports) 

Wood C

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Totally Tourism Ltd

- Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association

- Fairfax A

- Faul P

- Giddens B

- Saville A

Appeal lodged 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2018-CHC-065

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Wakatipu Equities Ltd 

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Trustees of the Burgess Duke Trust Ltd

- Gallagher D

Notice of Withdrawal

- Lawrence S

Notice of Withdrawal

 

- Otago Regional Council

Notice of Withdrawal

 

- Broomfield D and Woodlot properties Ltd

Waiver for late notice

-  Robertson D

Notice of Withdrawal

 

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, McFadgen L, Strain A, S and S, Crown Investment Trust, United Estates Ranch Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

Notice of Withdrawal

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order-Topic 31

Environment Court Decision

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-066

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Visitor Accommodation 

Crown Investment Trust

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5 Further Particulars

 

-  Hardley T

- Van Asch H and A

Notice of Withdrawal (Hardley and Van Asch)

- Airbnb

- Otago Regional Council

- Majordomo Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Caran Family Trust

- Touch of Spice Ltd
Notice of Withdrawal

- Felzar Properties Ltd, McFadgen L, Morven Ferry Ltd, Strain A, S and S, United Estates Ranch Ltd, Wakatipu Equities Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL

- Williamson S

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order Issued (Topic 31)

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-067

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

 

Arrowtown Lifestyle Retirement Village 

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

- Banco Trustees Ltd & Others

- Lawrence S

- Gallagher D

- Otago Regional Council

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, McFadgen L, Strain A, S and S, Crown Investment Trust, United Estates Ranch Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

Appeal Withdrawn

Notice of Withdrawal

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-068

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

McFadgen L

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4 

- Otago Regional Council

- Gallagher D

- Lawrence S

- Marc Scaife

Waiver

Appeal Withdrawn - notice of withdrawal

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order-Topic 31

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-069

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning (Ladies Mile)

Tylden M

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

Appendix 6

Appendix 7

 

Appeal Resolved

Consent Order 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-070

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning (Ladies Mile)

 

GW Stalker Family Trust

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

Appendix 6

Appendix 7

 

 Appeal Resolved

Consent Order

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-071

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin (Informal Airports)

Chapter 36 - Noise 

Fairfax A

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

- Faul P

- Giddens B

- Saville A

- Wood 

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-072

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin (Informal Airports)

Chapter 36 - Noise 

Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association (NZ) Inc

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

- Faul P

- Giddens B

- Saville A

- Wood C

 Appeal Lodged  

Consent Order Issued

 

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-073

Chapter 31 - Signs

 

Go Media Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

Appeal lodged 

Consent Order

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-074

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Slopehill Joint Venture

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

- Graeme Todd Family Trust

Notice of Change to Party List

- Brial M

- Otago Regional Council

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, McFadgen L, Strain A, S and S, Crown Investment Trust, United Estates Ranch Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Miller Family Trust

- Williamson S

 

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order-Topic 31

Appeal Withdrawal

Environment Court Decision

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-075

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

 

MacColl D

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5 Further Particulars

- Otago Regional Council

- Morven Residents Association

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, McFadgen L, Strain A, S and S, Crown Investment Trust, United Estates Ranch Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order-Topic 31

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-076

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 29 – Transport

Chapter 31 – Signs

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones

Visitor Accommodation 

Wayfare Group Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

 

- RCL Queenstown Pty Ltd, RCL Henley Downs Ltd, RCL Jacks Point Ltd

Appendix 1

- Kāi Tahu

- Airbnb

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga

- ZJV (NZ) Ltd

- New Zealand Transport Agency

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

- Blackmans Creek No. 1 LP & Soho Ski Area, Darby Planning Ltd Partnership, Henley Downs Land Holdings and Henley Downs Farm Holdings, Treble Cone Investments Ltd

- Kawerau Jet

- Aurora Energy Ltd

Application for waiver of time

Memorandum of counsel in support of waiver of time

(Waiver granted via email directions 7.10.19)

Appeal Lodged 

 

Consent Order 

 

Consent Order (Topic 28)

Consent Order (Topic 32)

 

Notice of Withdrawal - Visitor Accommodation

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-077

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

United Estates Ranch Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

 

- J S Dennison Trust

- Otago Regional Council

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-078

Visitor Accommodation 

Glencoe Station Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

- Airbnb

- Majordomo Ltd

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Darby Planning Ltd Partnership

- Touch of Spice Ltd

- Christine Byrch

Waiver

 Appeal Lodged

 

7 May 2019

 

 ENV-2019-CHC-079

 

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character
Visitor Accommodation

Mt Christina Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

 

- Airbnb

- Otago Regional Council

- Majordomo Ltd

- May J

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Touch of Spice Ltd

- Christine Byrch

Waiver

 Appeal Lodged

7 May 2019

 

ENV-2019-CHC-080

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

 

Felzar Properties Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

- Otago Regional Council

Appeal Withdrawn

Notice of Appeal

7 May 2019

 ENV-2019-CHC-081

 

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Visitor Accommodation 

Glendhu Bay Trustees Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

- Airbnb

- Otago Regional Council

- Majordomo Ltd

- May J

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Darby Planning Ltd Partnership

- Touch of Spice Ltd

 Appeal Lodged

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-082

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Monk R

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Memorandum of counsel withdrawing appeal points

Amended Notice of Appeal 

 

Notice of Withdrawal 

- Banco Trustees Ltd & Others

- Otago Regional Council

- Lawrence S

Notice of Withdrawal

- Gallagher D

Notice of Withdrawal

Appeal Lodged 

 

Consent Order Issued

 

Consent Order-Topic 31

Notice of Withdrawal

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-083

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin

Lake Hayes Investments Ltd 

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

- Otago Regional Council

- Guillot C and Y and Cook Adam Trustees Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019

 ENV-2019-CHC-084

 

 Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin

Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Williamson S

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5 

Appendix 6

- Moloney D 

- Hill RW and DK

- X-Ray Trust

- Millbrook Country Club Ltd

- Otago Regional Council

- Robertson D

Notice of Withdrawal

- Harwood S

- Hurle N

- Nancekivell M and P

- Rouse J

- Rouse W

- Nelson L and J

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-085

 

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 24 – Wakatipu Basin

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Chapter 29 – Transport

Visitor AccommodationRezoning

Darby Planning Ltd Partnership

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appednix 3a

Appendix 3b

Appendix 4

 

- RCL Queenstown Pty Ltd, RCL Henley Downs Ltd, RCL Jacks Point Ltd

Appendix 1

- Transpower New Zealand

- Kāi Tahu

- Airbnb

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Majordomo Ltd

- May J 

Memo of withdrawal-J May

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Crown Investment Trust

- Touch of Spice Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

- Caran Family Trust, Felzar Properties Ltd, McFadgen L, Morven Ferry Ltd, Strain A, S and S, United Estates Ranch Ltd, Wakatipu Equities Ltd

Notice of Withdrawal (Felzar)

- Williamson S

Appeal Lodged – Notice of withdrawal -Part withdrawn as relates to Topics 30 and 31

Consent Order Issued

Consent Order (Topic 28)

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-086

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Barnhill Corporate Trustee 

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

Appendix 6

Appendix 7 Further Particulars

Memorandum of Counsel

 

- Transpower New Zealand

Notice of Withdrawal 



- Lawrence S

Notice of Withdrawal

- Gallagher D

Notice of Withdrawal


- Otago Regional Council

ORC - Notice of Withdrawal 

Appeal Lodged 

Consent Order Issued

Environment Court Decision

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-087

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Chapter 36 - Noise

 

Lake Hayes Cellar Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4 

Appendix 5 Further Particulars

- Otago Regional Council

- May J -Memo of Withdrawal

 

 Appeal Lodged

Notice of Withdrawal

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-088

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

 

Morven Ferry Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

Appendix 6

Appendix 7 Further Particulars

Memorandum of Counsel 

- Transpower New Zealand

Notice of withdrawal

- Otago Regional Council

ORC - Notice of Withdrawal

Appeal lodged 

Consent Order Issued

 

Environment Court Decision

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-089

 Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 24 – Wakatipu Basin

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Lake Hayes Ltd 

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Transpower New Zealand

- Kāi Tahu

- Otago Regional Council

- Guillot C and Y and Cook Adam Trustees Ltd

- May J  - Memo of Withdrawal

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Queenstown park Ltd

Appeal Lodged – Notice of withdrawarl Part withdrawn as relates to Topics 30 and 31’

Consent Order Issued

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-090

Chapter 24 – Wakatipu Basin

Rezoning (Ayrburn)

Urban Growth Boundary

Waterfall Park Developments Ltd 

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3  

- Appendix 3a 

- Appendix 4

- Appendix 5

- Appendix 6

- Appendix 7 Further Particulars

- Hadley J and R

- Millbrook Country Club Ltd

- Otago Regional Council

- Wilkinson J and Thomssen T Notice of Withdrawal 

- Andersson J

- McGuinness PA Ltd

- Friends of Lake Hayes Society Incorporated

Appeal Lodged 

 

Consent Order Issued

 

Environment Court Decision

Environment Court Decision

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-091

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Treble Cone Investments Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Kāi Tahu

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- May J

- Remarkables Park Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-092

Wakatipu Basin Outstanding Natural Landscape Line

Speargrass Properties Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

 

Consent Order (Appeal Resolved).

 

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-093

 

Chapter 24 - Wakatipu Basin Rezoning

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Taylor M and J

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Otago Regional Council

- Wilkinson J and Thomssen T   

Notice of Withdrawal

Appeal Resolved

Consent Order

 

 7 May 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-094

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Blackmans Creek No. 1 LP and Soho Ski Area Ltd

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

- Kāi Tahu

- Otago Regional Council

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- May J

- Remarkables Park Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

7 May 2019

 ENV-2019-CHC-095

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Chapter 27 – Subdivision and Development

Chapter 29 – Transport

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones
Rezoning (Jacks Point)

Visitor Accommodation

 

Henley Downs Farm Holdings Ltd and Henley Downs Land Holdings Ltd

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

-RCL Queenstown Pty Ltd, RCL Henley Downs Ltd, RCL Jacks Point Ltd

Appendix 1

- Transpower New Zealand

- Kāi Tahu

- Airbnb

- Otago Regional Council
NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- Majordomo Ltd

- New Zealand Transport Agency

- Remarkables Park Ltd

- Bachcare Ltd

- Bookabach Ltd

- Touch of Spice Ltd

- Wayfare Group Limited

Appeal Lodged 

 

Consent Order (Topic 28)

Consent Order (Topic 32)

7 May 2019 

ENV-2019-CHC-096

Wakatipu Basin

Outstanding Natural Landscape Line

Bridesdale Farm Developments Ltd (Appeal A)

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

 Appendix 3

-Appendix 4

- Appendix 5

- Queenstown Country Club Ltd and Queenstown Commercial Ltd

 Appeal Withdrawn

7 May 2019

 ENV-2019-CHC-097

Chapter 38 - Open Space and Recreation Zones

Rezoning (Bridesdale)

Urban Growth Boundary 

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning (Ladies Mile)

Bridesdale Farm Developments Ltd (Appeal B)

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Appendix 4

- Appendix 5

- Appendix 6

- Appendix 7

- Appendix 8

- Appendix 9

- Queenstown Park Ltd

- ZJV (NZ) Ltd

- Queenstown Airport Corporation Ltd

- Remarkables Park Ltd

Appeal Lodged 

22 May 2019

 

 

 

 

ENV-2019-CHC-099

Wakatipu Basin Rezoning 

Chapter 6 – Landscapes and Rural Character

Chapter 25 – Earthworks

Hogans Gully Farming Limited

- Appendix 1

- Appendix 2

- Appendix 3

- Application for Waiver of Time

 

Appeal Lodged 

Waiver Granted 

Consent Order - Topic 31

2 July 2019

ENV-2019-CHC-110

Chapter 2 - Definitions 

Trojan Helmet Ltd

Memorandum of counsel re amended Notice of Appeal

Notice of Appeal (amended, tracked)

Notice of Appeal (amended, clean)

Waiver Decision

- Otago Regional Council

- Gibbston Valley Station Ltd

- Hannan

- Hogans Gully Farming Limited

Appeal Lodged